Author: Lisa Graas, assisted by Grok.
In the often tumultuous relationship between former U.S. President Donald Trump and Pope Francis, there have been moments of discord, particularly concerning issues like immigration and climate change. However, despite these differences, there are several areas where the actions or policies of Trump’s administration align with Catholic teachings or could be seen as commendable from the perspective of the Catholic Church. Here’s a look at some points Pope Francis might find praiseworthy:
1. Judicial Appointments: Donald Trump’s administration appointed several conservative judges, three of whom were confirmed to the Supreme Court: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett. These appointments have had a significant impact on U.S. jurisprudence, notably in the overturning of Roe v. Wade with the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision in 2022. This move aligns with the Catholic Church’s staunch pro-life stance, which Pope Francis has consistently upheld, despite his broader call for social justice and care for the marginalized.
2. Religious Freedom Advocacy: Under Trump’s leadership, the U.S. saw policies aimed at enhancing religious freedoms. His administration implemented changes that allowed for broader exemptions for religious organizations from certain federal regulations, which was particularly beneficial for faith-based schools and charities. For instance, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos made adjustments to promote religious liberty in educational contexts, which could resonate with the Church’s mission to protect religious expression and practice.
3. Support for Israel: Trump’s recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and the subsequent move of the U.S. embassy there was a significant geopolitical decision. While the Vatican has traditionally supported the status quo in Jerusalem to respect the rights of all religious communities, Trump’s action aligns with a broader Christian sentiment of supporting Israel as a gesture of solidarity with the Jewish people.
4. Prison Reform: The “First Step Act” signed by Trump in 2018 aimed to reform the criminal justice system, reducing mandatory minimum sentences and promoting rehabilitation over mere punishment. This aligns with Catholic social teaching on the dignity of every human person, advocating for mercy and second chances, which Pope Francis has emphasized in his own teachings and actions.
5. Efforts to Combat Human Trafficking: Trump’s administration took steps to address human trafficking, including the establishment of a White House position specifically to combat this issue. This initiative could be seen as supporting the Church’s long-standing fight against modern slavery, a cause Pope Francis has vocally championed.
6. Economic Policies with Family Values: Some of Trump’s economic policies, like tax cuts aimed at stimulating business and employment, indirectly supported family structures by promoting job creation. While the Pope has criticized aspects of capitalism, he has also called for policies that support families and alleviate poverty, areas where these economic strategies might be viewed positively for their intent.
7. Appreciation for Law Enforcement: Trump’s support for law enforcement, including initiatives like “Back the Blue”, might resonate with the Church’s teaching on the respect for law and order, while also advocating for justice and peace, areas where Pope Francis has spoken on the need for balance between security and rights.
In conclusion, while the relationship between Pope Francis and Donald Trump has been marked by public disagreements, there are facets of Trump’s presidency that reflect values the Church upholds. Acknowledging these could provide a foundation for dialogue on how to move forward in serving the common good, even amidst differing approaches to governance and policy.
